A Critical Assessment of Thomas Carlyle’s Great Man Theory and its Explanatory Paradox for Political Leadership Performance in Nigeria
Keywords:
Great Man Theory, Leadership, Nigerian leadershipAbstract
Despite decades of democratic transitions, constitutional revisions, and economic reform initiatives, Nigeria continues to suffer from persistent governance deficits, institutional decay, systemic corruption, and political instability. This development which can be termed a colossal mishap has continued to generate serious philosophical questions. Central to this argument is whether the responsibility of good governance rests squarely on the leader or a collective responsibility involving the leaders and the led. The paper examined the explanatory strengths and limitations of Carlyle’s Great Man theory in understanding leadership performance in Nigeria. In particulars, the paper evaluated the strength of Carlyle’s traits of great leaders in understanding the challenges of
leadership performance in Nigeria; the interface between Thomas Carlyle’s need for great leader and leadership in Nigeria; and the limitation of Carlyle’s traits of great leaders in understanding the challenges of leadership performance in Nigeria. While relying on the Thomas Carlyle’s Great Man Theoretical framework, the paper utilizes the Historical-Comparative (HC) approach of qualitative design. It relied on secondary method of data collection, and qualitative content analysis for data analysis. The paper concluded that the strength of Great Man Theory should be adopted as a guiding principle in electing political leaders who will help build and stabilize institutions and structures that will guarantee good governance and accountability in Nigeria.